Whitethorn Woods

by Maeve Binchy

Assignment: #1 of popular novel annotations
Publication info.: Alfred A Knopf, 2007. 339 p.
Genre & Format: Drama Comedy; Novel—written as interconnected short stories
Awards/Reviews: Review in Library Journal and Kirkus Review
Grades: 10 and up

Summary: The town of Rossmore in Ireland is home to a shrine in the woods which brings visitors from near and far begging for health, wealth, and happiness—and sometimes just answers. The interconnection of the folks that live there, are from there, have relatives there, or have emigrated from there is delightfully played out to the end. Neddy (my hero), is a plain, Forrest Gump type fellow, who is often underestimated, however he is lucky enough to have a handful of people that see his smarts and integrity. Father Brian Flynn is unnerved by the piety of visitors to the shrine, including his sister looking for love. The ones that have moved to London always seem to have an air that just proves you are always better off staying in Ireland if you want to continue to be good people. The American relatives are predictably American, but not in a stereotypical manner, just typical of Binchy’s portrayal of them in the past. In the end some are happy while others get their due.

Comments: For a student (mostly girls I’m afraid) that likes nice stories about people that seem real and make you laugh, this is a great book. There is no sex, drugs, or rock and roll—however in the Irish storytelling tradition, there is a bit of the drink. There were occasions where she would introduce a new character’s life and I would not feel drawn in, but a couple of pages later there would be the best twist that I did not see coming about that person. That might be half Maeve, and half my lack of foresight when I enjoy popular literature—I like to just let it unfold for me.

For classroom use: The opposing viewpoints on a situation would make a great example for a narrative writing exercise showing two very different takes on an event. Easy reading, great as a read-aloud, even for boys.

Booktalking ideas: I might booktalk this at the beginning of March for St. Patrick’s themes. I would also consider mixing this in with a chic lit booktalk for upper high school. Maybe summarize one of the subplots, then ask them what they think the point of view might be from the other characters—especially the bits about Becca’s plan to get her man.

VOYAesque Rating: 5Q 3P